Dark times, for the light that shows that freedom lives.
In 1956 Lord Devlin described trial by jury as “lamp that shows that freedom lives.” Lord Devlin explained, “The first object of any tyrant in Whitehall would be to make parliament utterly subservient to his will; and the next to overthrow or diminish trial by jury, for no tyrant could afford to leave a subject’s freedom in the hands of 12 of his countrymen. So that trial by jury is more than an instrument of justice and more than one wheel of the constitution: it is the lamp that shows that freedom lives.” (Emphasis added)
This Labour government tried to overthrow trial by jury for certain offences, something which I opposed. Prime Minister Burnham has since ditched these disgraceful proposals. However, over the past week, in the aftermath of the conviction of Russell Brand, there has been a serious attempt by those in power to diminish trial by jury in the case of rape.
Trial by jury, that lamp that shows that freedom lives, means little if the State dictates to a defendant how he can defend himself. This includes restricting the cross-examination of an accuser; unreasonably limiting what can be said to the jury in a closing speech by defence counsel; and strict judicial directions to the jury on how they must weigh crucial evidence.
The State v the man
In the very serious case of rape, the team prosecuting the defendant is substantial. The police gather the evidence, the Crown Prosecution lawyers (which could be many) put together the indictment which can include multiple charges over a significant period of time and dating back a decade or more. At trial there are CPS solicitors, a junior counsel and senior counsel. That’s quite a substantial team with the resources of the state at their disposal pursing a conviction against a man which will result in a custodial sentence.
A defendant has a solicitor, a junior counsel and senior counsel. In truth, there are about three people standing between this man and 10 years in prison.
This isn’t a game.
The legal revolution in the case of rape.
The law and rules of evidence on the offence of rape has changed substantially over the last 100 years. It was the case a jury could not convict on the uncorroborated evidence of a complainant. A mere complaint would not even be left to a jury to consider. This rule was abolished and replaced by a judicial warning given by the trial judge to the jury that it was dangerous to convict on the uncorroborated evidence of a complainant. This rule was then abolished.
Under Blair, the rules of evidence in all cases are now less favourable to a defendant. Centuries old prohibitions on hearsay evidence and evidence of previous convictions or bad character were abolished. In certain circumstances these can be presented by the Crown to the jury.
The general rule, that the probative value of any evidence must outweigh its prejudicial effect, remains. The trial judge must ensure a fair trial.
The fallout after Brand
There has been much criticism of how Brand’s counsel, Mr Ian Winter KC conducted his defence. This wasn’t just from cranks on the internet, but the Prime Minister, the Deputy Prime Minister, the head of the Metropolitan Police and the Rape Crisis Centre.
Sir Mark Rowley, the Metropolitan Police commissioner, said how Brand’s defence lawyer put his case in closing “came close to victim blaming.” Rowley told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme on Friday that some of what was heard in Brand’s trial was “getting very close to victim blaming.” He continued, “It shouldn’t be possible for inaccurate statements to be made to a jury to suggest that because a rape victim didn’t behave in one way, that somehow that undermines their case, when the evidence is very clear, we’re all very different [in] psychological and personal make-up, and in the most extraordinary horrific moments, of course, people react very differently.”
The Metropolitan Police commissioner has no business dictating to defence counsel what they can say in a closing speech.
The Prime Minister then followed up saying that rape victims should not be left “feeling like they are on trial.” The PM added, “I think we need to constantly look at the way rape trials are conducted to make sure that they do not leave the woman feeling like she is on trial in court, as has been the experience of people in the past.”
But the English criminal justice system is an adversarial system. It is inevitable that if a woman makes an allegation of rape against a man, which he denies, that cross-examination will be challenging. Giving evidence in such circumstances will be traumatic, it would be childish to pretend otherwise. Increasingly, any challenge to a complainant’s evidence is now deemed victim blaming.
Labour’s deputy leader, Lucy Powell, further described the cross-examination on behalf of Brand as “depressing” saying she believed the courts had “long gone past that sort of culture.”
Even the Guardian admits “the way the victims were questioned by the disgraced comedian’s legal representative, Ian Winter KC, has been criticised in recent days.” This is an attack not just on Brand’s counsel, but the right of all defendants to a fair trial. It will be increasingly difficult for defendants in rape cases to get a fair trial if they are to be limited in how they put their defence case.
There was criticism of how Mr Winter KC cross-examined the complainants, what he said in his closing speech, and even his plea in mitigation before sentencing. Mr Winter KC pointed out that a complainant should not be considered vulnerable, which is a legal term of art. On this legal point he succeeded. One commentator on X said, “Ian Winter, Brand’s defence barrister’s reputation will surely be in the gutter after this trial.”
Mitigation is an extremely important part of a defence counsel’s duty to his client. It can make the difference between 10 or 8 years in custody. Two years of a man’s life is considered cheap by some.
Even the Criminal Bar Association sought to insert itself between a defendant and his counsel, which is highly inappropriate. The Criminal Bar Association exists to represent the views of the practising members of the Criminal Bar in England and Wales not to praise the sentencing remarks of a trial judge. Its Chair and Vice-Chair, said “We welcome the piercing clarity of the judge’s statement. Myths about rape and sexual assault must play no part in our culture or in our courtrooms. Raping or sexually assaulting someone is a crime, and blame lies entirely with the perpetrator.” The CBA should stick to representing those who represent men and women accused of very serious crimes.
The Rape Crisis Centre also attacked defence counsel. “Ciara Bergman, the chief executive of Rape Crisis England & Wales, said (Judge) Bennathan’s remarks were “hugely important” at the end of such a high-profile trial…“This recognition stands in stark contrast to the appalling accusations made by Brand’s defence barrister, who perpetuated myths, misconceptions and conceptions about rape, such as needing to have fought, screamed or reported immediately for it to be considered a credible allegation. Of course this is not the case; there are a range of ways in which people respond to the threat of an imminent sexual assault and all of them are valid.”
All of them are valid. In other words, any reaction or non-reaction by a rape complainant is of probative value and little can be said that might undermine an accusation made by a complainant. This is no longer a trial by jury. This is trial by feminism.

(Above, trial by water, a form of trial by ordeal.)
Women – angels who never lie.
The direction of travel in rape cases should worry any fair-minded person. The political and media narrative is now, all victims should be believed and any challenge to a complainant’s evidence is myth making or a misconception. Can a defendant say anything in his defence to a charge over two decades old?
Women are almost untouchable, angels who never lie. This itself is a myth. Women, like men, sometimes lie. Women, like men, also lie to themselves and can construct a narrative to fit a certain vision of themselves.
If you are a man who faces an allegation up to twenty years old, there are inherent challenges to defending yourself. Memories fade and details can change. Today, there are additional limits on what one can say in one’s defence; you cannot question a complainants previous sexual history; what she may have worn or drunk on a night in question; or, even how she reacted after the assault. Mr Winter KC came in for particular criticism when he pointed out that none of his victims had “resisted or screamed or even tried to leave.” But these comments were made in a closing speech of some length, which the media have conveniently picked out for moral condemnation.
So-called “Rape Myths” and the Catch-22
There is now a list of so-called “rape myths.” We are told by those who know better (i.e. the feminists) – that it is a myth to say that a woman will always resist being raped either physically. We are told it is myth that only a truthful complainant will report a rape to the police soon after the attack. Instead, the experts claim, it is more accurate to say that a woman will not always fight back, either physically or verbally and a lengthy delay in reporting an attack to the police is perfectly understandable and should not be held against the victim.
The use of the term “myth” however is prejudicial to a defendant. It means the probative value of a piece of evidence has already been decided by those who know better before the evidence is even put before a jury.
In effect, we are told that to even ask why a complainant did not resist an attack either physically or verbally is ‘victim blaming.’ If a woman does not physically or verbally resit at the time, juries are told, it doesn’t mean it was not rape.
Again I assume however that if she does resist, it is evidence that she was raped.
Likewise, a jury cannot even consider a lengthy delay in reporting an allegation to the police in their deliberations as those that know better have labelled the idea that a delay might make the allegation less true as a ‘myth.’
I assume however that if a woman reports an allegation of rape immediately this will be used by the Crown as evidence of honesty, trustworthiness and truthfulness.
So what, exactly, is a defendant permitted to say either in cross-examination or in closing? This is a classic catch-22 for the defendant.
Judicial Directions.
Judicial directions is another area where the right to jury trial can be diminished. It is not a fair trial if the judge is going to burden the jury with directions and instructions that have been drawn up by feminist industrial complex or the women’s studies department of some university.
On Monday the House of Lords will debate a proposal for further judicial directions. An amendment tabled in the Lords would require judges to give juries dealing with sex offences or domestic abuse a “direction on myths and stereotypes” unless satisfied that it was unnecessary in specific circumstances. Lord Burnett, speaking during a debate on the proposal in the Lords, said it “is unprecedented for Parliament to seek to instruct judges on how they should direct juries, as opposed to laying down the substantive law, and that to do so would be an unacceptable intrusion upon judicial independence.”
This is also an unprecedented interference by Parliament into jury deliberations. A jury is told, directed, that they can bring their own life experience and common sense to deliberations. Pure prejudice is not permitted.
Therefore we should trust a jury to take the evidence as a whole. When it comes to cross-examination juries often do not take kindly to aggressive questioning of a complainant in rape cases. Let’s consider this issue of, she never fought back at the time. This is very context based. Most jurors will know that physically resisting is futile in the case of rape given the height and strength difference between men and women. Does this really have to be pointed out explicitly to them by a judge?
Further, to make clear, I am only talking about what a defendant should be allowed to leave to a jury for their consideration. Defence counsel do not get to choose their client and they do not get to choose their client’s case. They must put the case to the complainant, but they cannot humiliate them. Nor, can counsel knowingly mislead the court. These are all well-established rules of law. Defence counsel presents distasteful or even outlandish defences to juries every day of the week.
I do not remember this level of outrage at how a defence case was conducted when Muslim men were on trial for very serious offences of rape and child trafficking in the north of England. There were some very nasty defences run in those cases, such that the underage victims were girlfriends of a defendant or the victim lied about her age. I suspect the pleas in mitigation contained many unattractive elements. Defence counsel were not named and shamed in the papers on those cases.
The chipping away of a fair trial
It is not any one rule that I object to but the cumulative effect of both concrete rules of evidence, judicial directions along with political comments and media hysteria that constitute a dangerous and unfair attack on the right to trial by jury. In the words of Lord Devlin, taken together this diminishes a man’s right to trial by jury.
When I was talking about this with a colleague he said that this was not a hill he was prepared to die on. But when it comes to trial by jury, a lot of people did die on actual hills. It is a right explicitly claimed in Magna Carta (Clause 39), and also cited in the American Declaration of Independence as a justification for seeking independence.
What we have seen over the last few days is not just a predictable media feeding frenzy over a once famous man now destroyed by his own wrongdoing. There has been a very subtle but dangerous attack on the right to a fair trial itself. Lord Devlin warned against an overthrow or diminishing of trial by jury.
That is exactly what the Prime Minister, the Deputy Prime Minister, the Met and even the Criminal Bar Association have done in the last week, diminished the right of trial by jury.
It should be resisted.
From lauraperrins on substack
Disclaimer: We at Prepare for Change (PFC) bring you information that is not offered by the mainstream news, and therefore may seem controversial. The opinions, views, statements, and/or information we present are not necessarily promoted, endorsed, espoused, or agreed to by Prepare for Change, its leadership Council, members, those who work with PFC, or those who read its content. However, they are hopefully provocative. Please use discernment! Use logical thinking, your own intuition and your own connection with Source, Spirit and Natural Laws to help you determine what is true and what is not. By sharing information and seeding dialogue, it is our goal to raise consciousness and awareness of higher truths to free us from enslavement of the matrix in this material realm.
EN
FR

























