Public health officials blame “ignorance” for vaccine refusal. Data from six Western countries tells the exact opposite story. (Part 1)
Note: This is Part 1 of a two-part series. Coming next in Part 2: When “Educating the Public” Fails, Out Comes the Iron Glove: How France and Italy Turned a Normal Childhood Illness into a Police State Mandate.
The information provided herein is for informational purposes only. It is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health care provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition or treatment and before undertaking a new health care regimen, and never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read herein.

Do Cleverer Women Choose Not to Vaccinate? Some of them even Doctors?
Public health officials blame “ignorance” for vaccine refusal. Data from six Western countries tells the exact opposite story. (Part 1)
If you ask a standard public health official who refuses childhood vaccines, they will offer a very tidy, comforting explanation. In their influential 2001 paper titled ‘Understanding those who do not understand,’ prominent vaccinologists Professors Gregory Poland and Robert M Jacobson of the Mayo clinic, Minnesota, framed vaccine refusal as a simple deficit of comprehension.1 This narrative has been set in stone ever since: Vaccine Hesitancy equals Ignorance. People say, ‘No,’ because they, ‘don’t understand the science.’
There is just one problem with this theory. When you look at the actual numbers from studies in the UK, Israel, Norway, France, Italy and the USA this comforting narrative collapses. The mothers leading the refusal don’t fail to understand the science. They understand it only too well—and that is precisely the problem for vaccine proponents.
The Great Parenting Flip
To see what is really happening, you have to look at history, because the social class of parenting has completely flipped on its head over the last seventy years.
Back in the 1950s and 60s, if you were a clever, university-educated mother, you were the ultimate champion of “scientific parenting.” You trusted medical authority implicitly. You gave up breastfeeding because infant formula was marketed as a modern, scientifically superior upgrade, leaving breastfeeding to poorer women who couldn’t afford the tins. And when the new polio and measles vaccines arrived, educated mothers were at the front of the queue, demanding access to protect their children from visible, terrifying diseases.
Then, between the late 1970s and the turn of the millennium, the script flipped. First, educated women read the emerging immunological science, abandoned formula tins, and turned extended breastfeeding into the ultimate badge of middle-class motherhood.2
Shortly after, that exact same demographic shift hit the vaccination clinic.
The Evidence Across Europe and Israel and the USA
Today, across the Western world, active vaccine refusal is overwhelmingly an affluent, educated choice.
The UK Data: In a landmark 2008 British cohort study, Pearce and colleagues tracked over 14,000 children and found that mothers with a university degree were significantly more likely not to let their child have the MMR vaccine — or to use their financial clout to pay for single-antigen jabs instead. Nearly three-quarters of these mothers weren’t forgetting appointments; they made a “conscious decision” to opt out.3
Dan Anderberg, Professor of Economics at Royal Holloway University of London and his team, took advantage of the MMR ‘scare’ in the late 1990’s to carry out their own survey. He found three things:
“The uptake rate of the MMR declined faster in areas where a larger fraction of parents had stayed in education past the age of 18 than in areas with less educated parents.”
“The same areas reduced their relative uptake of other uncontroversial childhood immunizations, suggesting a “spillover” effect.”
“A corresponding positive income effect, indicated that wealthier parents avoided the MMR dilemma by purchasing single vaccines.”4
The Israeli Data: Israel is a country with universal healthcare and high compliance. Here the pattern becomes even sharper right inside the maternity ward. A study by Maayan-Metzger et al, Sheba Medical Center, in 2005 found that mothers who actively refused the routine day-one Hepatitis B shot for their newborns were significantly more educated and older than those who complied. Those who accepted vaccination were more likely to have “trust in the doctors.”5 Fifteen years later, a 2020 prospective study by Fridman and colleagues confirmed the exact same profile: refusers were predominantly middle-class, educated mothers who exclusively breastfed, practised rooming-in, and had actively researched multiple sources of information.6
Indeed public health research by Aharon and team in 2017 unearthed what they regarded as counter intuitive information that:
“The results indicate that parents with high functional, communicative, and critical health literacy are more at risk of not vaccinating their children.
“The results are contrary to expectations”7
The Norwegian, French, and Italian Figures: The trend holds even when vaccines are handed out for free at school. A massive study of over 90,000 girls in a 2015 nationwide register study in Norway by Feiring and others found that higher maternal education was significantly linked to a lower likelihood of a daughter initiating the free Human Papilloma Virus [HPV] vaccine.8 A 2021 follow-up study across six birth cohorts by Bjerke et al confirmed the same but the difference was now no longer so pronounced.9 Similarly, national surveys in France and Italy—two of the most vaccine-sceptical nations in Europe—found hesitancy clusters disproportionately among the well-educated. Even more inconveniently for public health authorities, surveys across Europe consistently show high rates of hesitancy among healthcare workers themselves. Yes, some of the women saying, ‘No,’ are doctors.10
USA
A Systematic Review of almost 750 studies published between 2002 and 2022, focussing on the USA looking to see why parents refused MMR vaccine found again:
“Vaccine hesitancy to MMR and other childhood vaccines clustered in middle- to high-income areas among mothers with a college-level education or higher who preferred internet/social media narratives over physician-based vaccine information. They had low parental trust, low perceived disease susceptibility, and were skeptical of vaccine safety and benefits”
For a highly referenced paper it was interesting that there was no reference for the opening claims that, “Vaccines are the most effective public health measures against infectious diseases.” and, MMR has been proven to be safe and effective.…” (see my Vaccination Report for more on this)
The authors went on to decry that:
“The lack of information verification and quality control with online sources [which] can exaggerate the risk for adverse events while downplaying the benefits of vaccines.”11
“Lack of information verification and quality control” – they could have been talking about vaccine safety studies.
Why They Understand Too Well
Why do clever, educated women—including medical professionals—reject standard protocols? Because they are applying the exact critical thinking skills their universities taught them.
When an educated mother walks into a maternity unit and refuses a birth-dose Hepatitis B vaccine or routine antibiotic eye ointment , she isn’t confused. She knows Hepatitis B is blood-borne and sexually transmitted. She knows chlamydia and gonorrhoea are sexually transmitted. She has looked at her own clean prenatal screening, assessed her monogamous lifestyle, and calculated that her newborn’s immediate risk of contracting these infections is virtually zero.
She understands the difference between population-level policy (which treats every baby as high-risk to prevent a single administrative slip-up) and individual risk (where her specific baby does not need the intervention). She refuses to subject her healthy newborn to a blanket medical protocol designed to cover systemic gaps in screening.
The Losing Battle
Professors Gregory Poland and Robert M Jacobson, still don’t get it: “Understanding those who do not understand.”12
But they do understand. This is exactly the problem for Governments and Public Health Departments, given ever more bizarre titles, like the UK Health Security Agency [UKHSA] who launch endless campaigns to “educate” hesitant mothers as if they were naughty schoolchildren who failed basic biology.
They are fighting the wrong war. You cannot patronise a college or university-educated mother—let alone a female doctor—into compliance with a simplified public health leaflet. These women aren’t rejecting vaccines because they don’t understand the science. They are rejecting them because they understand statistics, they understand individual risk, and they refuse to let the state treat their child as a statistical rounding error. Until the medical establishment stops treating informed dissent as ignorance, and changes its policies, the cleverest women in the room will keep walking out the door.
From drjaynelmdonegan on substack
Disclaimer: We at Prepare for Change (PFC) bring you information that is not offered by the mainstream news, and therefore may seem controversial. The opinions, views, statements, and/or information we present are not necessarily promoted, endorsed, espoused, or agreed to by Prepare for Change, its leadership Council, members, those who work with PFC, or those who read its content. However, they are hopefully provocative. Please use discernment! Use logical thinking, your own intuition and your own connection with Source, Spirit and Natural Laws to help you determine what is true and what is not. By sharing information and seeding dialogue, it is our goal to raise consciousness and awareness of higher truths to free us from enslavement of the matrix in this material realm.
EN
FR

























